Opinion Blogs vs Discussion Blogs

dukeo.com

Most blogs fall into one of two categories: They’re a discussion blog, where they provide information and let the reader form their own opinion, or they’re opinion blogs, where the blogger takes a firm stand on the issues. You’ll find plenty of blogs out there that try to blend the two, but most will lean to either one side or the other. Does it make any difference to your business? And is one better than the other? Let’s take a look.

opinion discussion

A discussion blog provides information without expressing an opinion. News websties are a good example. The typically present both sides of the issue and then invite discussion. Discussion-type blogs typically attract readers who are looking for information. They want to know the pros and cons and they’re happy to form their own opinion.

On the other hand, opinion blogs usually take a stance. For example, a political blogger may be staunchly Republican or firmly on the side of the Democrats. His blog posts may present both sides of the issue but you’ll also find his opinion in there somewhere. These types of blogs also invite discussion, but of a different sort.

In a discussion blog commentors will often ask for more information or thank you for sharing. In an opinion blog, you may never hear the words “Thank You”. In fact, you might not like the comments you receive. However, if you’re the type who enjoys a lively discussion, then you’d probably love to write an opinion-type blog.

There’s a saying that controversy sells and in some ways it’s true. People are attracted to controversy. It’s like a wreck on the side of the road. You can’t help yourself, you’re drawn to the drama so you have to slow down. So yes, controversial or opinionated posts do tend to attract more traffic and get more share and likes. However, that doesn’t necessarily mean they make more money.

People are drawn to controversial content more for the entertainment value. They’re not looking for information, they’re just looking for a good fight. Once you’ve developed a good following it’s possible to getter a better gauge on your readers and decide how to monetize this type of blog but it’s difficult in the beginning.

Is it possible to meld the two? Absolutely. In fact, I find it easier to run a discussion blog and toss in a little controversy or opinion every now and then just to liven things up. My readers appreciate the occasional burst of fire and brimstone and, since they’ve had the opportunity to get to know me when I’m not all fired up, I don’t get angry responses from my commentors. They’re more forgiving because we’ve already developed a give and take relationship.

You, on the other hand, might feel stifled and bored blogging endlessly about statistics or information and you might prefer to go the opinionated route. There’s plenty of room in the blogosphere for everyone, no matter how you blog. And either way you go, the key to monetization is to get to know your audience first so you can find out what they need.

Sté Kerwer
Article written by Sté Kerwer (1994 Posts)
Bonjour from a french guy. My name is Sté Kerwer and Dukeo is my blog. I do most of the heavy lifting in here but from time to time, you may see some guest posts. To receive updates from Dukeo, follow us on Twitter or like us on Facebook.
If you enjoyed this article, Get email updates
JOIN FOR FREE

2 Comments (Add one)

  1. dennie

    If an “opinion” blog can stimulate discussion, then perhaps the nomenclature might be changed?

    When I read your title, I first thought: blogs that *tell* you how to think (Opinion) vs. blogs that invite you to think with them (Discussion). (“Tell” implies more tone and attitude e.g. everyone who doesn’t agree is dumb)

    Isn’t a blog, by its definition, an opinion? Even straight facts collated creates an argument of some kind unless it’s pure raw data.

    What I love about all blogs is the opportunity to have a discussion with folks I might not otherwise know. Thank you! for opening a door on your side :-)

    1. Sté Kerwer

      I like to think of it as the difference between a lecture and a workshop… In a lecture, one person is passing down their knowledge or opinion. On the other hand, a workshop invites people to discuss a subject and to create something new.

Leave a Reply

When posting a comment, please use your personal name, not your business name. I find it a lot more interesting to talk with people instead of talking with brands.